Industry Insights
April 28, 2025

How to Choose the Right Property Management Company

Tips for selecting the best property management company for your rental property.

Owning rental property can be a lucrative investment, but managing it effectively requires time, effort, and expertise. A property management company can help take the burden off your shoulders, handling everything from tenant screening to rent collection and maintenance. However, not all property management companies are created equal. Choosing the right one can mean the difference between a profitable investment and a stressful experience.

Understanding What a Property Management Company Does

A property management company serves as the intermediary between landlords and tenants, ensuring smooth day-to-day operations. Their responsibilities often include:

  • Marketing rental properties and filling vacancies
  • Screening and selecting tenants
  • Collecting rent and handling late payments
  • Coordinating maintenance and repairs
  • Ensuring legal compliance with lease agreements and local housing laws

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Property Management Company

Experience and Reputation

A company with a solid track record in the industry is more likely to deliver reliable service. Research how long they have been in business and look at their online reviews. Ask for references from current clients to get a sense of their performance and reliability.

Services Offered

Not all property management companies offer the same level of service. Some may only handle leasing, while others provide full-service management, including maintenance, legal compliance, and financial reporting. Make sure their offerings align with your specific needs.

Tenant Screening Process

Tenant quality directly impacts rental income and property condition. A good property management company should have a thorough screening process that includes background checks, credit history, rental history, and employment verification.

Fee Structure

Most property management companies charge a percentage of the monthly rent, typically between 8% and 12%. Some may also charge additional fees for lease renewals, maintenance, and marketing. Be clear about their fee structure and ensure there are no hidden costs.

Rent Collection and Eviction Policies

Timely rent collection is crucial for maintaining cash flow. A property management company should have a clear system for collecting rent and handling late payments. Additionally, ask about their eviction process to ensure they follow legal procedures while minimizing losses.

Maintenance and Vendor Relationships

Property maintenance is an ongoing concern for landlords. A good property management company should have relationships with reliable contractors and vendors to handle repairs quickly and cost-effectively.

Legal Knowledge

Rental laws vary by state and city, so working with a company that understands local landlord-tenant laws is essential. This helps prevent legal issues and ensures compliance with fair housing regulations.

Why Hiring a Property Management Company is Worth It

Managing rental properties requires time, expertise, and problem-solving skills. By hiring a professional property management company, landlords can enjoy benefits such as:

  • Reduced Stress: No more late-night maintenance calls or dealing with difficult tenants.
  • Increased Profitability: A skilled management company can minimize vacancies and optimize rental rates.
  • Legal Protection: Compliance with property laws and regulations reduces the risk of costly lawsuits.
  • Efficient Maintenance: Established vendor relationships lead to faster and more affordable repairs.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right property management company is one of the most important decisions a landlord can make. A great company will protect your investment, maximize rental income, and handle the daily tasks that come with property ownership.

If you're a landlord struggling with unpaid rent or tenant disputes, Advanced Collection Bureau specializes in debt recovery for rental properties. We offer skip tracing, credit reporting, and expert collections, ensuring landlords recover what they’re owed efficiently and legally.

Recover More.
Stress Less.

Unpaid debts should not slow down your business.

We specialize in professional and compliant debt recovery, helping you maximize recoveries while maintaining strong customer relationships.

Our risk-free, results-driven approach ensures you only pay when we collect.

Get in Touch

Owning rental property can be a lucrative investment, but managing it effectively requires time, effort, and expertise. A property management company can help take the burden off your shoulders, handling everything from tenant screening to rent collection and maintenance. However, not all property management companies are created equal. Choosing the right one can mean the difference between a profitable investment and a stressful experience.

Understanding What a Property Management Company Does

A property management company serves as the intermediary between landlords and tenants, ensuring smooth day-to-day operations. Their responsibilities often include:

  • Marketing rental properties and filling vacancies
  • Screening and selecting tenants
  • Collecting rent and handling late payments
  • Coordinating maintenance and repairs
  • Ensuring legal compliance with lease agreements and local housing laws

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Property Management Company

Experience and Reputation

A company with a solid track record in the industry is more likely to deliver reliable service. Research how long they have been in business and look at their online reviews. Ask for references from current clients to get a sense of their performance and reliability.

Services Offered

Not all property management companies offer the same level of service. Some may only handle leasing, while others provide full-service management, including maintenance, legal compliance, and financial reporting. Make sure their offerings align with your specific needs.

Tenant Screening Process

Tenant quality directly impacts rental income and property condition. A good property management company should have a thorough screening process that includes background checks, credit history, rental history, and employment verification.

Fee Structure

Most property management companies charge a percentage of the monthly rent, typically between 8% and 12%. Some may also charge additional fees for lease renewals, maintenance, and marketing. Be clear about their fee structure and ensure there are no hidden costs.

Rent Collection and Eviction Policies

Timely rent collection is crucial for maintaining cash flow. A property management company should have a clear system for collecting rent and handling late payments. Additionally, ask about their eviction process to ensure they follow legal procedures while minimizing losses.

Maintenance and Vendor Relationships

Property maintenance is an ongoing concern for landlords. A good property management company should have relationships with reliable contractors and vendors to handle repairs quickly and cost-effectively.

Legal Knowledge

Rental laws vary by state and city, so working with a company that understands local landlord-tenant laws is essential. This helps prevent legal issues and ensures compliance with fair housing regulations.

Why Hiring a Property Management Company is Worth It

Managing rental properties requires time, expertise, and problem-solving skills. By hiring a professional property management company, landlords can enjoy benefits such as:

  • Reduced Stress: No more late-night maintenance calls or dealing with difficult tenants.
  • Increased Profitability: A skilled management company can minimize vacancies and optimize rental rates.
  • Legal Protection: Compliance with property laws and regulations reduces the risk of costly lawsuits.
  • Efficient Maintenance: Established vendor relationships lead to faster and more affordable repairs.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right property management company is one of the most important decisions a landlord can make. A great company will protect your investment, maximize rental income, and handle the daily tasks that come with property ownership.

If you're a landlord struggling with unpaid rent or tenant disputes, Advanced Collection Bureau specializes in debt recovery for rental properties. We offer skip tracing, credit reporting, and expert collections, ensuring landlords recover what they’re owed efficiently and legally.

Recover More.
Stress Less.

Unpaid debts should not slow down your business.

We specialize in professional and compliant debt recovery, helping you maximize recoveries while maintaining strong customer relationships.

Our risk-free, results-driven approach ensures you only pay when we collect.

Get in Touch

Collect More.
Pay Less.

You don't pay anything until we collect.

We report to credit bureaus twice as often as most agencies, ensuring faster recoveries. Plus, we never charge interest on debts - just simple, transparent collections.

Our contingency-based model means you do not pay unless we collect.

Let's Get Collecting

More Simplicity.
Less Surprises.

No confusing contracts. Just good debt recovery.

We believe in complete transparency. That’s why we report to credit bureaus twice as often as most agencies, never charge interest on debts, and keep our contingency fee model simple -
if we don’t collect, you don’t pay.

Debt recovery should be hassle-free. With us, you get results without the guesswork.

Contact Us

Discover Our Array of Services

Dense luxury apartment housing
Apartment Communities

Extensive experience recovering debt from multi-unit rental properties. We understand the challenges of high tenant turnover.

Get in Touch
Photo of multifamily homes from the street
Single-Family Rentals

Adept at tracking down past-due tenants across houses, condos, and townhomes. Persistent efforts to recover your owed rent.

Learn More
Students inside a upscale student residence
Student Housing

Familiar with the unique aspects of collecting from student renters. Well-versed in handling cosigner and guarantor situations.

Learn More
A group of people walking into a beautiful vacation rental.
Vacation Rentals

Skilled at recovering debt from short-term rental properties. Experienced in navigating guest contracts and security deposits.

Learn More

Ready to See Your
Cash Flow Improve?

Find out how we can help you recover your debts

A comfy blue chair